Saturday, July 14, 2012

BROKE STATES

“Ask not what your country can do for you. Most of the politicians are corrupt anyway.” Rita Coolidge

It is official. State governments are going under because they have no funds to keep basic services going. Bankruptcy which faces many state governments has long been foretold by many governors, and the protracted arguments over paying the N18,000 minimum wage have been identified as both cause and the consequence of many states, particularly those from the north, going broke. But the Senate says States are going broke because governors are corrupt. Its Ad Hoc Committee on National Planning, Economic Affairs and Poverty Alleviation, Appropriation, Finance as well as States and Local Governments which examined the causes of the looming bankruptcy in many states, recently concluded that it is the result of financial recklessness of many governors. The senators say corruption through misappropriation and misapplication of public funds and abuse of immunity clause in the constitution is responsible for the threat of bankruptcy in States.

Perhaps it should surprise no one therefore that State governors have decided to challenge the Federal Government over deductions and withdrawals for such items as payments for petroleum subsidy, Excess Crude Account and the Sovereign Wealth Fund. They say these deductions and withdrawals are unconstitutional, and they will ask the Supreme Court to decide whether they should continue or not.

Governors’ grievances over deductions to pay the massive and highly disputed fuel subsidy was in part responsible for the decision to withdraw the subsidy on petroleum. It soon became clear that the partial withdrawal has neither resolved the basic issues of transparency and accountability in the oil and gas sector; nor put the issue of the acceptability of amounts deducted to rest. Government is still paying a much higher amounts than it should for the reduced subsidy, and state governments’ “take-home-pay” from monthly fund allocation meetings has become leaner and more unpredictable. Governors complain that they do not understand or accept the process which deprives them of large expected amounts. They want an end to deductions to pay for subsidy, and this should raise their monthly allocations. If all subsidy has to be removed, so be it, but they will not say so.

They also want a judicial ruling of the Federal Government’s desire to create a Sovereign Wealth Fund to replace the Excess Crude Account, a facility which currently makes available the resources of all tiers of government for massive, unplanned drawdown. Intense and delicate negotiations, lobbying and discussions have been going on to prevent the Governors from taking the Federal Government to court over the legality or propriety of the Sovereign Wealth Fund (SWF). Realizing that it will not win a legal battle over the SWF, the Federal Government had opted to convince Governors of the value of the facility, emphasizing its benefits of saving for investment in infrastructure and the real sector, and shielding huge resources from being used to address immediate recurrent needs and overheads of governments. Until this decision to challenge the establishment of the SWF, the Federal Government had virtually established a framework for its operation, and with anywhere between $1b to $5b reported to be available for it, and a target of $10b being lobbied for, it appeared as if the Federal Government was winning its battle to save for the rainy day. There was some talk of partial buy-in by some governors, and fierce resistance from partisan interests. The intense efforts put in by Dr Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala to bring the Governors around to some agreement now appears to be coming unstuck. A legal dispute will substantially delay the take-off of the SWF, and render the excess crude funds amenable and available for continuous, routine plunder.

Viewed against the claim by the Senate that mismanagement and corruption, and not dwindling resources are responsible for the imminent bankruptcy of many states, how is the clamour for increased funding by State Governments from oil and gas revenues to be understood? One perspective may be informed by the accepted wisdom that Governors will never have “enough” resources to misappropriate, maintain basic services and institutions of state, as well as invest in real development. One or two have said they have enough to develop, and a few others have concentrated on raising more revenues internally instead of crying out for more funds from oil and gas sources. A second perspective may place the senators’ conclusions in a context which suggests that they are ill-equipped to comment on the management of resources at state levels. They lack the moral courage to criticize, in the light of their own massive remunerations. They do not have to take difficult decisions which Governors take in managing costly public services, oiling political machines and investing in infrastructure. A third perspective may highlight a wider issue on the merit of revisiting the manner revenues are shared between the three tiers of government.

State Governors have made a credible case for a review of the revenue allocation formula which should give them a larger share. There is a lot of sympathy for this position, as well as the basic underlying argument that the federal government should be relieved of many of the functions it performs, which it uses as rationale for its current share of revenue. States therefore want more funds for more tasks, or at least to perform their tasks better.

The basic problem is one of trust. The public does not trust State Governments to use additional resources judiciously, with very few exceptions. In circles where serious discussions around the amendment of the constitution are conducted, state governments are reminded that their demand for additional funds will enjoy wider and more credible support if they accede to the demand that local governments should enjoy unfettered financial and political autonomy. There are also serious questions regarding the quality of management of public funds, with waste and corruption being the hallmark of much of governance in most states.

Ordinarily, State governments should mount a vigorous public campaign in support of the legal steps they are taking to challenge the federal government over the deductions and withdrawals from oil revenues. But they are likely to lose the battle because the public will be hard put to join in a cause which merely seeks to transfer funds from the federal to state governments, disburses funds now which could be saved. Neither level enjoys much credibility in terms of the manner it handles public funds. Yet there are good reasons why the issue which Governors say they will take to the Supreme Court should be discussed more widely. The manner the excess crude account has been approached with a predatory attitude by federal and state governments should not be tolerated. While there are good reasons to create flexible access to these types of funds for critical, short-term needs, these have hardly been the uses to which they have been applied in the past. The creation of a Sovereign Wealth Fund will be strongly advised in a country like Nigeria where revenue volatity and massive corruption, which are in part fed by easily available resources, characterize the political economy. With forecasts of dipping prices of crude being made, revenues from oil will be placed under even more stress.

There ought to be an open and constructive national discussion around the manner oil and gas revenues are derived and utilized. A dispute limited to the federal and state governments over who should have more, or whether we should save or spend will be largely ignored by the public, which sees little difference in the manner the two tiers manage our resources. States going broke may secure more resources if a judicial ruling says they should; but this is highly unlikely to improve the lives of most Nigerians.

Sunday, July 8, 2012

EDO GUBERNATORIAL ELECTIONS: BALLOTS AND BULLETS


“Democracy is too good to share with just anybody.”
H. L. Mencken

If you are voter in Edo State who believes that your vote should and must count, you must be wondering whether it is safe to exercise your right to decide who becomes Governor of the State this coming Saturday. Certainly, it will take the bravest of citizens to venture out either on campaign trails or to vote, given the intimidating mobilization of security personnel, particularly soldiers, reportedly in their thousands for the Saturday elections. It will be safe to say that the bullet will be as important as the ballot in determining who is announced as winner in the elections.
All the indices that the elections of a Governor on the 14th of July in Edo State will be a bitterly-fought affair have been evident for quite some time. Edo State has historically been a major battleground. If forms the core of the Midwest region, carved out with muscle and clout of the northern influence in the first republic. Subsequently, it remained the barometer for judging the balance of power between the West, and political parties with a heavy dose of northern and minority influences such as the NPN and PDP. The loss to either has been seen as a major setback, and the stakes have never been higher than they are. The Action Congress of Nigeria of Governor Adams Oshiomhole and the People’s Democratic Party which straddles the nation’s political horizon like a colossus are locked in a bitter battle to show who is the dominant influence in a key state and region. A win by Oshiomhole will weaken the PDP’s stranglehold on the south-south, and may very well signal the political end of some of the most powerful fixers of the PDP. A loss by the ACN will represent a major setback for a party which wants to claim that quality governance can take it beyond narrow ethnic boundaries in Nigeria.
The most visible and obvious indicator that the voting is unlikely to reflect the popular will is the massive deployment of thousands of soldiers and other security personnel days before the elections. In the absence of clear signs that voters and election officials are likely to face serious threats which a deployment on this scale alone can mitigate, the question has to be asked what all this militarization of the voting process seeks to achieve. On the basis of experience, Nigerians know that the visible presence of heavily-armed soldiers scares voters from venturing out to vote. Low turn-outs create opportunities to manipulate ballots and result sheets. Soldiers intimidate voters and observers who want to exercise their rights to keep the entire process in sight.
The militarization of the voting process tends to generate its own image. Interests that cannot mobilize the military in their favour resort to their own use of violence as a political tool. Long before elections, campaigns become violent and dangerous affairs; communities are torn by rival armed gangs; simple folk are warned in advance of the consequences of voting one way or the other; and the whole community arms itself to the teeth using money from politicians. Arms used to intimidate the public will be retained after the elections. They will be turned against the same politicians who bought them, or against the community later.
The electoral process will be severely compromised in this type of atmosphere. Allegations of intimidation, ballot stuffing, results without voting or use of violence at polling stations will be made. Agents will allegedly be chased away, and whole communities or voters will complain that they were prevented from going to polling units or collation centers.
These may very well be the reasons why this type of mobilization of armed security personnel is being made. Whoever is declared winner after the Saturday elections, there will be another loser: the citizens of Edo State who will never be sure that the results genuinely reflect their will, or the will of a few fixers and professional election riggers.
For the rest of Nigeria, the elections in Edo State this weekend are also very important. What happens in this particular election will indicate whether the government and INEC have learnt any lessons from previous elections. It may give a hint on whether President Jonathan and his party, the PDP are willing to test their popularity in open, free and fair elections; or they will continue with the tradition of muscling results out of the system.
Even at this stage, Nigerians should demand that the Edo gubernatorial elections coming up on Saturday must be demilitarized. If there is evidence that some people intend to use violence or some other illegal means to influence the outcome of the elections, the police and other security agents should deal with this threat, not thousands of soldiers. INEC should demand a freer and less intimidating environment, openly and specifically, because it cannot claim to conduct a free and fair election in an environment where voters are having to choose between ballots and bullets.

NIGERIA: THIRD QUARTER TOP 10 WATCH LIST


“You can tell a good Friday from the Wednesday preceding it”.
Hausa Proverb
This watch list focuses on issues, activities, developments or actors with the potential to affect the Nigerian political economy in the period, July to September, 2012. It is not exhaustive, and the criteria for selection have been informed by current national concerns, developments and linkages with other issues outside the list. The watch list is meant strictly as a guide towards areas or issues that may inform government policy or shape public opinion.
10. The Rainy Season
The rainy season in Nigeria has always had two contradictory impacts. It is the period during which the nation’s major investments in agriculture are made. It is also the season which tends to expose the weaknesses and limitations of basic physical and social infrastructure, as well as the capacity of the state to respond to them. The rainy season in this quarter will bring widespread damage to socio-economic infrastructure which governments have ignored to fix; and widespread complaints, particularly from the northern part of the country, that fertilizer is still too expensive for small producers to access.
9.   Ngozi Ononjo-Iweala
The Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister for the Economy is potentially a very powerful person in the management and reform of the nation’s economy. Her first year in office has been marked by massive turbulence around issues relating to deregulation and liberalization policies. This quarter should indicate the degree to which she is succeeding in pushing the frontiers for reform, or accepting the limited space and scope with which she has operated so far.
8.   The Sovereign Wealth Fund
The fate of this instrument intended to shield national resources from endemic plunder and creating a stable resource base for real investment may be decided this quarter. The deadlock between the federal government and governors over the size of the fund and the existence of serious political issues around a consensus towards achieving at least $10b in the fund will either cripple it substantially, or be resolved by more effective political negotiations.
7.   The Federal Cabinet
There has been much speculation over the fate of many ministers in a rumoured shake up. Elaborate details have been leaked and denied by the administration, leading to intense lobbying and loss of morale among ministers. The period under review should indicate whether the President is willing to bring on board fresh and more capable hands, or even sack untouchables in his cabinet who represent major sources of weaknesses in his administration.
6.   Fuel Subsidy Investigation
The federal government has just set up another committee to investigate, verify and reconcile the findings of the technical committee earlier established by the Federal Ministry of Finance to conduct a detailed review of all subsidy claims and payments that were made in 2011. The committee has only one week to conclude an assignment into an issue over which many other committees have also been involved. The national assembly’s effort have registered a major casualty among its ranks, which has quite possibly fatally injured its own report. There are many other reports of investigations, and even the E.F.C.C. is supposed to have received information which could be acted upon to prosecute those involved in the subsidy scam.
This period should indicate the sincerity of the federal government in exposing those involved in the scam, and willingness to tackle widespread corruption in the oil and gas sector.
5.   National Security Adviser
The new National Security Adviser may substantially improve the prospects for some type of truce and commencement of engagement with JASLIWAJ (a.k.a Boko Haram), or he may turn out to be even more powerless than his predecessor. The frenzy of contacts, visits and media engagements in which he has been involved since his appointment suggest that he believes that governors, traditional rulers and public opinion are critical to his success. If he is wrong in identifying these as sources for the resolution of the issues raised by the insurgency, he would have missed a critical period within which to make an impact. Major indicators for gauging his success include the degree to which he influences activities of security agencies, and whether he represents a credible mediatory avenue, either on his own or with others. The caliber, clout and pedigree of the person to be appointed Minister of Defence will also be an important success factor for the NSA.
4.   Jama’atu Ahlil Sunnah Liddaawati Wal Jihad (a.k.a Boko Haram)
With the Ramadan fast starting in July and a new National Security Advisor vigorously waving olive branches, this period should indicate whether this insurgency has the cohesiveness and foresight to take political decisions that go beyond fighting state agents and christians. If it calls a truce during the Ramadan period, and it is able to sustain it, it could strengthen its hands in any discussion with the government. Its continuing threat and potential to cause widespread havoc has been amply demonstrated in Kaduna State recently.
3.   The Elections in Edo State
All the indices for a bitterly-fought gubernatorial election in Edo State have been registered. The PDP is desperate to defeat the sitting governor, and even President Jonathan has had to undergo a personal humiliation at the palace of the Oba of Benin in his bid to enlist influential support. The governor himself will throw everything at the PDP, and the electoral process will be severely stressed in this election. The fallout of these elections will be registered well beyond the elections themselves, and politically-related violence will most likely rise. The Edo elections are critical because they have a direct relationship with 2015.
2.   Northern Governors
Northern governors have retreated substantially from effective governance since the middle of 2011. Serious incursions of JASLIWAJ (Boko Haram) activities in many parts of the north have introduced a heavy and crippling federal presence through security agencies’ activities in the North. Declining resources to make any real impact, (especially with the N18,000 minimum wage burden) have made northern governors largely irrelevant in terms of development and politics in the north and Nigeria. The period under review should either see an initiative to recapture lost ground by the governors through populist rhetorics or use of proxy groups, or a further decline in their influence as they retreat from the threat and damage of JASLIWAJ and the poverty of their citizens.
1.   President Goodluck Jonathan
President Jonathan has not demonstrated a strong political will and character to lead this nation out of its severely crippling challenges and limitations so far. Deepening and expanding corruption and the increase in the scope and damage of the JASLIWAJ insurgency have created the image a weak and ineffective President. This period should indicate whether the President can generate and deploy a stronger will and demonstrable competence in managing the affairs of state; or he will continue to operate in a manner that suggests that the solutions to the nation’s problems may come from anywhere else, but him.
     General Overview
The third quarter of 2012 is likely to be marked by intensification of violence by the JASLIWAJ insurgency and efforts to frustrate genuine efforts to expose and deal with corruption which occurs substantially around the administration. There are likely to be issues around ineffective and weak implementation of the budget, and wider clamour for improvements in accountability by leaders. Real improvements in the quality of governance or effectiveness of policies to eradicate poverty and insecurity are not envisaged.

Friday, June 29, 2012

DECODING SENATOR DAVID MARK


“When a dog sniffs at a shoe, you can be certain it will take it away.” Hausa Proverb

At the end of November last year, I posted a comment under the translated Hausa proverb above, when the chorus of demands that northern leaders should find solutions to the insurgency by the JASLIWAJ (aka Boko Haram) was becoming loudly registered. I recall my good friend Bishop Mathew Kukah querying me about its meaning when I sent the comments to him, and I explained that the proverb warns of an impending event, or a suspicion that remote signals would translate into certain events. Within one week in that November, last year, Mrs Sarah Jibril, Special Adviser to President Jonathan and Pastor Oritsejafor, who carries his cross like a sword all the way to the Presidential Villa both demanded that northern leaders (read: northern muslims) should do more to curtail and eliminate the insurgency. The messages in both comments were the same: put out the fire you lit before it consumes the whole nation. It will be useful to recall some parts of those that comment I made in November, 2011:

There have been other comments which suggest that northern leaders resent their inability to install Shari’a in the north; or their loss of political power, and have therefore created Boko Haram to provide a violent alternative to achieve political goals… The emphatic repudiation of the linkages by spokesmen of the insurgency does not appear to have changed minds among those who are bent on visiting the entire Boko Haram phenomenon on the scheming or failures of northern leaders.

The dangers in attempts to identify the Boko Haram insurgency as a northern issue, and to hold its leaders responsible for it, are many. One is that the view will inform the adoption of the wrong strategy to deal with the problem. Resources and energy will be directed at chasing politicians and the clergy, while the problem grows. Another is that the fight against a national threat will become politicisized and pitch sections of the country against each other…. Thirdly, a strategy which seeks to blame northern leaders for responsibility or failure with regards to Boko Haram will merely feed the insurgency. It will burn the bridges which the administration may need to build towards a resolution. It will make most northern leaders multiple victims, because they are neither safe from Boko Haram nor from the government. It will create new enemies for an administration which needs all the support it can get from politicians, traditional rulers, the clergy and the public in its fight against the insurgency. Above all, it may give the administration a false sense of accomplishment when it thinks it has identified the enemy, whereas it is far from doing that.

The north should vigorously fight this attempt to isolate it and blame it for a problem which has made it a worse victim than all other parts of the country…

So, did Senator David Mark even hint at the need for northern leaders to find solutions to the insurgency at a retreat recently? Whatever he said, or said he did not say, the point is that the nation’s number three citizen alluded to the existence of a northern problem for which in plain terms, northern leaders (muslim, clergy, politicians) have full responsibility. Senator David Mark is in good company in this respect. Virtually every one, from the President down, who is not a northern Muslim has pointed accusing fingers at the northern Muslim community. A polite version of this concert is one which suggests that a community which harbours the insurgency at great cost to itself should be more active in the search for solutions. A more popular version is one which suggests that northerners should know members of the insurgency and should do something about them, or continue to pay the price. Either way, the muslim north is accused of anything from complicity, to indifference, to collaboration, or to active support.

The vigorous verbal gymnastics made by Senator David Mark to reduce the damage which he thought his comments may have caused were actually all unnecessary. Long before he joined the chorus, the north of which he now insists he is part and parcel, has been redefined by both the JASLIWAJ insurgency, its effect, and the reactions of Nigerian leaders. The concept of a political north is now fiction. There is a muslim north which is being defined by unceasing violence, damage and destruction which will take it the best part of two decades to mend, assuming that it does begin soon. It is the base and the hostage of an insurgency which has no respect for traditional values, institutions or structures. It is impotent against a movement which strikes it at will; and against a state security apparatus which treats it as the enemy. Its economy is crumbling; its social values are being challenged and eroded by spreading poverty and the impotence of its leaders; its political fortunes have crashed; and it may remain largely peripheral to the political process for many years to come.

Then there is the north of christians and ethnic minorities who live in fear of bombs from people they used to share a political affinity with. This is the north that seeks desperately to re-define itself, and create an identity from the vestiges of deep roots with the far north, and cultivated sentiments of minorities and victims.

If there is any value in what Senator David Mark said, or did not say he said, or said he did not say, it is that northern muslims should wake up to the reality that the rest of Nigeria (including northern christians) see the JASLIWAJ insurgency as essentially a northern muslim issue. Denying responsibility for it, or throwing their hands up in hopelessness will not win them sympathy or respite. The more the insurgency takes root in the muslim north, the higher the price it will pay. If this insurgency lasts for another one year, even at current levels of hostility, the economy of the far north will be completely devastated. Its population will be among the most traumatized in the world, and it is quite conceivable that the insurgency will be stronger than it is today. The far north may as well forget any claim to the right to offer leadership in Nigeria, under whatever guise or arrangement. It will be a spectator in a political system which has room only for tribes and religious faiths, and in which intense competition will expose its frailties and weaknesses. It will reach out in vain to the rest of Nigeria for a national endeavour to find solution to a national problem.

The challenge for the Muslim north is to take a hard look at itself, and pull itself out of its paralyzing stupor. There will be no helping hands from parts of the nation which stand to benefit from the devastation of the north. There will be no help from the leadership which thinks the north should put out its own fire, or be consumed by it. There will be no help from northern christians who see only threats and hostility from an insurgency which treats them as legitimate targets.

Northern leaders with genuine commitment to its interests and fortunes should now step forward and summon the courage to look their own problems in the eye. Berating Senator David Mark or other politicians from the north who distance themselves from its problems merely expose the poverty and impotence of the region. President Jonathan appears to have given substance to the perception that JASLIWAJ is a northern muslim problem by appointing a northern muslim as his National Security Adviser. There is also talk of appointing another northern muslim as Minister of Defence. This may be dangerous tokenism, or it could be an opportunity for the muslim north to engage in some critical self assessment. Either way, the Muslim north needs to know that it is on its own.

Thursday, June 28, 2012

FULL CLOSURE

“If you don’t like my opinion of you, you can always improve.” Ashleigh Brilliant.

Among the many vital requirements for good governance, the existence of openness and transparency in the manner Nigerian leaders manage our affairs is the most visible by its absence. An accountable leadership with a capacity to submit to the highest moral standards is absolutely essential as a requirement for the growth and development of our democratic system. In the last two weeks, those among us who had hoped that the massive shocks from revelations of the existence of unprecedented levels of corruption will nudge our leaders towards improving the manner they manage our affairs will be bitterly disappointed by insistence from both the legislature and the President that what they earn or own is none of our business as citizens.

President Jonathan stepped up first, and told a national audience that it is no one’s business what he owns or owes, since he has satisfied the law in declaring his assets. He was responding to questions over why he has not declared his assets publicly, as he did when he was deputy to President Musa Yar’Adua. Using un-presidential words, he said even when he made a public declaration as Vice President, his reason was that Yar’Adua himself had done it. Even then, he said, it was not proper, because it is not public declaration of assets by the President that will change the country. After all, he can always be investigated when he leaves office.

Really, Mr President? Should we assume then that you operate on two different moral standards? One, when you publicly declared your assets because Yar’Adua did so, even though it was improper and not a legal requirement. And the other, when you are fully in charge of the affairs of the nation, and choose not to declare publicly. Were you wrong then, or wrong now?

The issue has little to do with the law, and everything to do with the moral standards by which our President chooses to be judged. The inconsistency between his position as Vice President and now as President is damaging to his standing, and the President should have realized that backtracking from his earlier declaration will do him serious damage. Even if he could have gotten away with this damaging inconsistency, his corruption-ravaged watch should have been a major motive for sustaining a largely symbolic but profoundly moral gesture of making his assets declaration public.

And he is wrong in assuming that the public declaration of his assets will not change the country. Everything Presidents do, or fail to do, or refuse to do can and do change the country. Nigerians do not want to wait until President Jonathan leaves office before he is investigated. Nor are they particularly concerned with his wealth, unless he has something to hide. But they do want to know that he is insulated from some of the earth-shaking scandals around the fuel-subsidy scam, the pension scam, the Malabu Oil scandal, and the serious damage which the absence of openness and transparency can cause to the integrity of leaders. Simply put, President Jonathan, under the circumstances, can only be accountable to Nigerians if he makes his assets public. If does not give a damn over their feelings over the matter, he needs to know that they give a damn.

But even before President Jonathan assesses the full impact of his unfortunate outing on national television, a Federal High Court in Abuja dealt another serious blow to efforts to keep a sealed lid on the income of our legislators. Justice Bilkisu Bello Aliyu ordered the Clerk of the National Assembly to disclose details of the salary, emoluments and allowances collected by members of the Senate and House of Representatives between 2007 and last year. A non-governmental organization, Legal Defence and Assistance Project had gone to court, using provisions of the Freedom of Information Act 2011 to demand the details of the fabulous take home pay of our legislators, saying that the issue affects public interest, since payments to the legislators are made from public funds.

The national assembly had objected to an earlier request for the details from the NGO. The law makers who passed the F.O.I Act after massive pressure had, even more amazingly, hired a Senior Advocate to argue before the judge that the NGO had no locus standi to make such a request. The technicality involved in the matter is not the issue. The real issue is that people elected to represent our interests do not want us to know how much we pay them or if they pay themselves more than they should.

The assault on open government which President Jonathan and the national assembly are leading will encourage the damaging perception that our leaders are dipping their hands in the till. This resistance against openness and accountability will fail, because more and more Nigerians will demand that our leaders live above board, and that we see them do so. Perhaps it is time to amend the law, and compel presidents and at least governors and legislators to declare their assets and liabilities publicly. All good friends of our legislature should also advise it to resist the temptation to appeal the ruling of the Abuja High Court on their emoluments. Its image right now can do without further damage.

Oops!
Last week I referred to N. Machiavelli as a Greek Philosopher. A few readers such as Ayo and Vita drew my attention to my error. He was Italian.