“Nothing is so admirable in politics as a short memory.”
J. K. Galbraith
Two days after the President’s ubiquitous godfather, Chief C.K. Clark demanded that northern leaders find solutions to the security problems posed by the insurgency of the Jama’atu Allil-Sunnati Lidda’awati Wal-Jihad (Boko Haram) a formidable group of northerners visited the Presidential Villa, reeled out a list of grievances of the people of the north, and demanded that President Jonathan finds solutions to them. They went under the umbrella of the Arewa Elders Forum, which is led by the Danmasanin Kano, Alhaji Maitama Sule. The image of a blind Danmasani in his 80s stooping to greet President Jonathan and Vice President Namadi Sambo will remain indelible in the minds of millions of Nigerians who have a deep cultural appreciation of body language and social hierarchies. Whether he stooped out of habit when he is before superior authority, or he did it to emphasise the abject humility of the group he led, that posture by Danmasani will be the second issue of significance, after the language and content of his address.
The Northern Elders Forum’s visit to President Jonathan must have been designed to convey a clear message that the North is angry, and holds the President and his security agencies or political associates largely responsible for what has become of the security, economy politics of the region. Even where they do not hold him entirely responsible, the long list of grievances and demands suggests that the elders believe that President Jonathan can find solutions to them if he wants to.
And the list of grievances and demands was very long indeed. The elders want the President to revisit many of the reports of investigations into ethno-religious conflicts, and implement their recommendations. They want the Boko Haram insurgency to be isolated from a wider, more dangerous context in which it is seen as a Muslim or northern resistance against the Jonathan administration, and the creation of the impression that the nation is involved in a war. They say that the insurgency, which they condemn, is providing reasons for gross abuses by security personnel, ranging from killings by the Joint Task Force in Maiduguri in thousands, to the latest practice of demolition or razing down residences where activities of Boko Haram insurgents are suspected. They also include detentions of thousands of suspects under dehumanizing conditions, and killings by starvation of detainees. The elders say similar incidents of illegal activities by security personnel which is leading citizens to lose confidence in agents of the state, and adopt self-reliance strategies to protect their lives and property are also evident in Kano, Damaturu, Azare, Gombe, Mubi and other areas. They invoke the authority of the American Secretary of State, Hilary Clinton, who said that the Nigerian security services are responsible for widespread abuses. They demand that security agencies change their modes of operation to gain confidence of the public.
The elders also wanted President Jonathan to call to order people close to him who are responsible for a resurgence of inciting sectional, ethnic and religious rhetoric which also condemns or disparages whole groups or sections, especially from the North. They want him to tackle corruption; stop the arbitrary and indiscriminate removal of senior officers in the Nigerian security and public services; address youth unemployment; stop relocation of military and other security formations or installations which raise suspicions; fund exploratory activities for hydrocarbon deposits in the north; address damaging disparities in revenue allocation between parts of the nation; and resume mediation efforts to dialogue with leaders of Boko Haram insurgency.
There were many more grievances and demands in the document made available to President Jonathan by the elders. It was not surprising that the President merely promised to study the litany of demands and get back to the elders in a few weeks time. If the President takes more than a few weeks to get back to the elders, they may very well be to blame. The elders’ shopping list will intimidate anyone, but to approach President Jonathan with them and demand immediate solutions will amount to overkill. If he does see them in a few weeks’ time, it may be in a private setting where he will tell them that he looks up to them as elders to help expose Boko Haram insurgents, their own children and grand children, who are responsible for the deployment of our entire security arsenal and modes of operation in parts of the north in the first place.
If he does see them in public, he may commit to ensuring that security agencies operate within the law, and in a manner which respects the rights of all individuals and communities. He may say that he had directed heads of security agencies to investigate reported breaches and deal with them. He may mention that the Shiekh Ahmad Lemu and Ambassador Galtimari Committees’ reports have been substantially implemented. He may complain that the biggest challenge in dealing with the Boko Haram insurgency is the insufficient support from communities, including support from Northern Elders, to deal with it at local levels, and that the scope exists for more effective collaboration between government, the communities, the muslim clergy and security agencies. He may say that his doors are open to dialogue with Boko Haram, and request the Elders to make efforts to persuade the insurgency to show itself for talks.
If he sees the elders, he may assure them of his commitment to preserve the unity of the nation. He may acknowledge that the constitution gives all citizens the rights to free speech, including speech which may appear targeted at the interests of a section or community. He may even remind the northern Elders that a northern politician recently made a statement about monkeys, dogs and bloody uprisings in relation to elections. He may appeal to the elders to help lower the political temperature of the nation, and assure all citizens that his government will protect them from people who are committed to violent upheavals and balkanization. Then he may inform them that he has referred all the other demands on their long shopping list to various ministries and other departments of government to assess and advise him. He will thank them for their sense of maturity at a time when the nation needs people like them, and assure them that his doors will always be open to them.
And then what? Will the elders all go back home satisfied that they have done what elders do, which is to step forward and mediate conflicts and provide wise counsel when it is needed? Do the elders have a plan ‘B’, a contingency arrangement which they will activate in the event that the silence from the Villa is long and loud; or that they get only platitudes and promises in return for their brave outing? Will they, for instance, meet with State Governors and speak with them with similar passion and candour, and give them a long to-do list on security and economy the north? Will they meet with other northern groups, community leaders, the clergy and young people and galvanize a pan-northern, community-based movement that will find genuine solutions to the Boko Haram insurgency, the dangerous and increasing marginalization of the north, and the reconstruction of the economy of the north?
It will be most uncharitable to take away from the Northern Elders the credit they deserve in the manner they spoke to power. But just in case power does not respond, one will expect that elders would have thought of options. Having seen the flag, there must be many groups and individuals from the north who would be happy to take it over from the Danmasani group, so that generations are spared the possibility that they will see elderly people like Alhaji Maitama Sule stoop before power in vain.
Saturday, June 2, 2012
Saturday, May 26, 2012
LEADERS BEHAVING BADLY
“Practical Politics consists in ignoring facts.”
Henry Brooks Adams
Yesterday, President Goodluck Jonathan celebrated the first year of his own full-bloodied presidency. If the last one year has been eventful, what will the next three be like? Better for Jonathan and the nation? More trying? Can we tell?
These are all legitimate questions to ask in a calm and relaxed environment. But the last two weeks have been anything but relaxed and calm. A huge uproar followed President Obasanjo’s reported claims that the legislature habours criminals and armed robbers, and so they cannot legislate well for the nation. The legislators demanded that he comes and identifies who among them is a criminal and an armed robber. If he does go, it will be a very long line up indeed. Old man C.K Clark enters the fray, and lambasts Obasanjo for pointing accusing fingers. He said a president who owned nothing in 1999 and is now one of the wealthiest men in the country should not speak about corruption.
The quarrel over who is corrupt and a criminal is being overshadowed by the story of how $1.1billion belonging to Nigerian people from the sale of an oil block was shared out to private companies with very close ties to government. Coming within the context of doubts being cast over the President’s political will and commitment to bring to book those identified as being involved in the mind-boggling fuel subsidy scam, this latest revelation will confound even the most de-sensitized Nigerian.
It will all be explained or denied of course, or some token gesture towards investigating will be made. The national assembly will make further incursions into President Jonathan’s territory by undertaking another probe and spectacular public relation outing that will show him as a poor manager. This will be the same institution which Obasanjo says is a den of thieves; the same one which offered damning conclusions on his privatization programme, and the same one which is being queried by the auditor-general for spending billions in un-retired funds. This is same national assembly which probed the fuel subsidy scam started under Obasanjo’s watch, whose report is being studied by the government and may be forwarded to the E.F.C.C. This will be the same E.F.C.C that was in place when the scam took pace, and which has substantial structural weaknesses that make it susceptible to political influences. This is the same E.F.C.C which is prosecuting legislators who allegedly received illegal funds and demanded for more from a public official they were “over-sighting.” This is the same public official who is currently under the close scrutiny of the national assembly for serious breaches in management of her agency and public funds. This is the same agency that was once headed by a chief executive officer who was prosecuted, and is being held responsible for the collapse of the Nigerian Capital Market. This is the same market that still operates substantially on the margins of acceptable standards, and is substantially victim of scheming of very tiny but extremely wealthy and powerful people. These are the same people who are being mentioned in the fuel subsidy scams. These are the scams which were successful only with the active collaboration of banks. These are the same banks that received and kept billions in embezzled funds from the pension scam. This is the same scam being alleged to be so elaborate that it will rope in some of the most powerful people around president Jonathan today, if they are genuinely investigated.
So the revelation and quarrels around incredible corruption are leaving their imprints all over President Jonathan’s one year old presidency. They are also setting an agenda for him, although very few people will expect that all the angles will be covered in the manner these investigation and allegations will be handled. What is certain is that many suspects will hire very expensive lawyers; they will tie up investigations and possible prosecution for as long as they want and there may even be one or two plea bargains involving sloppy deals.
Can this circle be broken? President Jonathan says most of the problems he deals with today have their roots deep in the past, certainly long before his watch began. Perhaps privately, he may even hold Obasanjo responsible for some of them. He could also blame the legislature of playing to the gallery when it choses to investigate certain aspects of the management of the economy, and then leaves him holding the baby, so to speak. Having aroused public sentiment on issues that should be handled with more rigour and scrutiny, the national assembly dumps “findings” on him and accuses him of not prosecuting people. The legislature will say it does its job; and may even query how it is possible that it does it better than the executive arm with its army of investigating agencies. People and organizations investigated by the legislature complain that the process is not transparent, in spite of television cameras and live coverage, and much of the investigation is motivated by considerations other than the search for the truth and pursuit of public interest. Trials on television and bullying by legislators are often heard from people who have been summoned, and while the public cheers and swallows everything it sees, there are complaints that these investigations bring up more mud than water.
In any case, the bottom line is that as President Jonathan celebrates his first year as President elected as a candidate, he needs to know that the institutional collapse under him is assuming alarming proportions. The public service – including regulatory and investigating agencies – are operating under the most challenging circumstances, the most prominent being strong signals that the political level does not welcome wholesale and genuine investigation into transactions and other government business. This is why the subsidy and pension scams can take place right under all the noses – or in collaboration with some elements – of the public service. The legislature will always exploit the opportunity to “oversight” the executive – and expose its weaknesses and shortcomings – and do this substantially at the expense of its more important responsibility, which is to make laws. When Obasanjo lashes at the National Assembly, he is reliving a very old war with a well-known adversary. This adversary will continue to encroach into President Jonathan’s territory in the manner he manages the economy, if he does not improve on his capacity to limit the damage of corruption. Protecting his turf will involve raising the standards by which he and his ministers and other managers of the public service operate. He has to personally distance himself from much of the muck presently flying around if he will be able to do this.
Henry Brooks Adams
Yesterday, President Goodluck Jonathan celebrated the first year of his own full-bloodied presidency. If the last one year has been eventful, what will the next three be like? Better for Jonathan and the nation? More trying? Can we tell?
These are all legitimate questions to ask in a calm and relaxed environment. But the last two weeks have been anything but relaxed and calm. A huge uproar followed President Obasanjo’s reported claims that the legislature habours criminals and armed robbers, and so they cannot legislate well for the nation. The legislators demanded that he comes and identifies who among them is a criminal and an armed robber. If he does go, it will be a very long line up indeed. Old man C.K Clark enters the fray, and lambasts Obasanjo for pointing accusing fingers. He said a president who owned nothing in 1999 and is now one of the wealthiest men in the country should not speak about corruption.
The quarrel over who is corrupt and a criminal is being overshadowed by the story of how $1.1billion belonging to Nigerian people from the sale of an oil block was shared out to private companies with very close ties to government. Coming within the context of doubts being cast over the President’s political will and commitment to bring to book those identified as being involved in the mind-boggling fuel subsidy scam, this latest revelation will confound even the most de-sensitized Nigerian.
It will all be explained or denied of course, or some token gesture towards investigating will be made. The national assembly will make further incursions into President Jonathan’s territory by undertaking another probe and spectacular public relation outing that will show him as a poor manager. This will be the same institution which Obasanjo says is a den of thieves; the same one which offered damning conclusions on his privatization programme, and the same one which is being queried by the auditor-general for spending billions in un-retired funds. This is same national assembly which probed the fuel subsidy scam started under Obasanjo’s watch, whose report is being studied by the government and may be forwarded to the E.F.C.C. This will be the same E.F.C.C that was in place when the scam took pace, and which has substantial structural weaknesses that make it susceptible to political influences. This is the same E.F.C.C which is prosecuting legislators who allegedly received illegal funds and demanded for more from a public official they were “over-sighting.” This is the same public official who is currently under the close scrutiny of the national assembly for serious breaches in management of her agency and public funds. This is the same agency that was once headed by a chief executive officer who was prosecuted, and is being held responsible for the collapse of the Nigerian Capital Market. This is the same market that still operates substantially on the margins of acceptable standards, and is substantially victim of scheming of very tiny but extremely wealthy and powerful people. These are the same people who are being mentioned in the fuel subsidy scams. These are the scams which were successful only with the active collaboration of banks. These are the same banks that received and kept billions in embezzled funds from the pension scam. This is the same scam being alleged to be so elaborate that it will rope in some of the most powerful people around president Jonathan today, if they are genuinely investigated.
So the revelation and quarrels around incredible corruption are leaving their imprints all over President Jonathan’s one year old presidency. They are also setting an agenda for him, although very few people will expect that all the angles will be covered in the manner these investigation and allegations will be handled. What is certain is that many suspects will hire very expensive lawyers; they will tie up investigations and possible prosecution for as long as they want and there may even be one or two plea bargains involving sloppy deals.
Can this circle be broken? President Jonathan says most of the problems he deals with today have their roots deep in the past, certainly long before his watch began. Perhaps privately, he may even hold Obasanjo responsible for some of them. He could also blame the legislature of playing to the gallery when it choses to investigate certain aspects of the management of the economy, and then leaves him holding the baby, so to speak. Having aroused public sentiment on issues that should be handled with more rigour and scrutiny, the national assembly dumps “findings” on him and accuses him of not prosecuting people. The legislature will say it does its job; and may even query how it is possible that it does it better than the executive arm with its army of investigating agencies. People and organizations investigated by the legislature complain that the process is not transparent, in spite of television cameras and live coverage, and much of the investigation is motivated by considerations other than the search for the truth and pursuit of public interest. Trials on television and bullying by legislators are often heard from people who have been summoned, and while the public cheers and swallows everything it sees, there are complaints that these investigations bring up more mud than water.
In any case, the bottom line is that as President Jonathan celebrates his first year as President elected as a candidate, he needs to know that the institutional collapse under him is assuming alarming proportions. The public service – including regulatory and investigating agencies – are operating under the most challenging circumstances, the most prominent being strong signals that the political level does not welcome wholesale and genuine investigation into transactions and other government business. This is why the subsidy and pension scams can take place right under all the noses – or in collaboration with some elements – of the public service. The legislature will always exploit the opportunity to “oversight” the executive – and expose its weaknesses and shortcomings – and do this substantially at the expense of its more important responsibility, which is to make laws. When Obasanjo lashes at the National Assembly, he is reliving a very old war with a well-known adversary. This adversary will continue to encroach into President Jonathan’s territory in the manner he manages the economy, if he does not improve on his capacity to limit the damage of corruption. Protecting his turf will involve raising the standards by which he and his ministers and other managers of the public service operate. He has to personally distance himself from much of the muck presently flying around if he will be able to do this.
PHEW!
“Don’t pay any attention to the critics; don’t even ignore them.”
Sam Goldwyn
Even President Jonathan will be forgiven if he is not sure whether his cup, at the end of his first year as president elected on his own, is half full, or half empty. To say the least, it has been an eventful year; and it will not be an exaggeration to say it may yet be his easiest year of the four he has been sworn to serve. If this has downed on him, it will be a sober President Jonathan who will be celebrating the first anniversary of his own Presidency tomorrow. If it downs on the people with whom he shares responsibility of running the nation, we should hear less of achievements, and more of a stronger commitment to fix the gaping holes in the administration’s record.
Two developments in the last week both define the character of Jonathan’s administration so far, and appear to be the basic issues which will determine his agenda in the future. The first is the emerging story about how $1.1 billion belonging to the Nigerian people from the sale of an oil block which belonged to Malibu oil was shared by private companies owned by people close to the presidency. The second is the statement credited to Chief C.K Clark, the President’s political godfather, that President Jonathan will run for the Presidency again in 2015.
The emerging story about the manner over N150 billion was shared out by private companies on instructions from top government officials will cast a pall on festivities and celebrations. In a nation whose citizens have been shocked beyond belief by scams and outright theft of incredible amounts, these last revelations will cap it all. It will be explained or rationalized, of course, and there may even be a token commitment to investigate. But Nigerians will not believe it. Instead, people are likely to cry once again to the high heavens for heads to roll. The same way they are demanding that heads roll from the fuel subsidy scam. The same way they want heads to roll over the pensions scam. The same way they want all the revelations from the investigations of the National Assembly to be followed up faithfully and culprits brought to book. The first year of Jonathan’s full-bloodied presidency may be recorded in history as the year of huge resistance against anti-people policies, and of monumental theft. A cynical citizenry will become even more distrusting as the administration subjects finding, reports and investigations to further scrutiny, which will allow suspects regain composure and confidence, and cover tracks with good lawyers and bureaucratic lethargy. Between the insurgency of the Jamaatu Ahlis Sunnah Lid da’awati Wal Jihad (Boko Haram) and corruption of unspeakable proportions carried out with chilling impunity, there will be little left for Nigerians to cheer in this anniversary.
It may have been noted by the President and his close advisers, but it needs restating that in two basic areas, this administration has failed very badly. These are in the areas of securing lives and property of citizens and promoting their welfare; the two basic functions of any government. The manifestation of organized violence and rampant violent crimes have rendered life for all Nigerians more precarious. The national assembly has moved into the vacuum created by incompetence and weak political will of the administration to expose how improvements in citizens’ welfare have been hijacked by rampant and entrenched corruption. The President lost much of his turf to organized violence and crimes, and the opportunism of politicians in the legislative arms. He will find it increasingly difficult to put out policies which involve additional hardships for the public, such as the forthcoming review on electricity tariff, if Nigerians hear only of stolen billions.
The second element which has defined the character of President Jonathan’s presidency, and is likely to define his agenda, is his political future beyond 2015. By now, when old man Clark speaks, the wise listen with rapt attention. When old man Clark and Pastor Oritsejafor say the same thing only the most foolish will be indifferent. And both say the only obstacle between Jonathan and another term from 2015 is a stubborn northern resistance, but it will be successfully challenged. Jonathan will run again in 2015 as it is his right to do, and in his interest to do. Others have done it before him, and those opposed to him are only doing so because he is from where he comes from. Nothing about competence, track record, ability or proven capacity to govern an increasingly difficult nation.
So Jonathan’s presidency will have one eye on managing an economy under assault from large scale corruption, and a polity threatened by organized violence and debilitating crimes; and the other eye on consuming maneuvers for 2015. How does he intend to handle these two simultaneously? Or, more significantly, what does he have that will enable him do this successfully? He certainly cannot rely on his public service to shore up deficiencies in integrity, competence and courage, when it is being routinely assaulted by arbitrariness, impunity and corruption. His entire arsenal of institutions and mechanisms intended to prevent the types of outright theft and fraud we see have been rendered laughable by the public stunts of the legislature which uses its oversight powers to show how a poor manager President Jonathan is. He will find it difficult to rely on the nation’s security asset to put an end to the insurgency which is crippling the north and threatening the rest of the nation, because it is more a part of the problem, than its solution. And though the brand new PDP leadership he has just helped install may give him some comfort, his party’s stranglehold on the nation’s political terrain is by no means guaranteed.
The problem for President Jonathan is that Nigerians are not sure who he is, or what he can do. If what they have seen of him in terms of managing crises, the economy or corruption is the Jonathan who wanted so badly to become President this time last year, they won’t be impressed. If there is more to President Jonathan than what Reuben Abati, C.K Clark or Pastor Oritsejafor say, he should show himself to Nigerians. The nation must not be run all the way to 2015, the way President Jonathan has run it so far.
Sam Goldwyn
Even President Jonathan will be forgiven if he is not sure whether his cup, at the end of his first year as president elected on his own, is half full, or half empty. To say the least, it has been an eventful year; and it will not be an exaggeration to say it may yet be his easiest year of the four he has been sworn to serve. If this has downed on him, it will be a sober President Jonathan who will be celebrating the first anniversary of his own Presidency tomorrow. If it downs on the people with whom he shares responsibility of running the nation, we should hear less of achievements, and more of a stronger commitment to fix the gaping holes in the administration’s record.
Two developments in the last week both define the character of Jonathan’s administration so far, and appear to be the basic issues which will determine his agenda in the future. The first is the emerging story about how $1.1 billion belonging to the Nigerian people from the sale of an oil block which belonged to Malibu oil was shared by private companies owned by people close to the presidency. The second is the statement credited to Chief C.K Clark, the President’s political godfather, that President Jonathan will run for the Presidency again in 2015.
The emerging story about the manner over N150 billion was shared out by private companies on instructions from top government officials will cast a pall on festivities and celebrations. In a nation whose citizens have been shocked beyond belief by scams and outright theft of incredible amounts, these last revelations will cap it all. It will be explained or rationalized, of course, and there may even be a token commitment to investigate. But Nigerians will not believe it. Instead, people are likely to cry once again to the high heavens for heads to roll. The same way they are demanding that heads roll from the fuel subsidy scam. The same way they want heads to roll over the pensions scam. The same way they want all the revelations from the investigations of the National Assembly to be followed up faithfully and culprits brought to book. The first year of Jonathan’s full-bloodied presidency may be recorded in history as the year of huge resistance against anti-people policies, and of monumental theft. A cynical citizenry will become even more distrusting as the administration subjects finding, reports and investigations to further scrutiny, which will allow suspects regain composure and confidence, and cover tracks with good lawyers and bureaucratic lethargy. Between the insurgency of the Jamaatu Ahlis Sunnah Lid da’awati Wal Jihad (Boko Haram) and corruption of unspeakable proportions carried out with chilling impunity, there will be little left for Nigerians to cheer in this anniversary.
It may have been noted by the President and his close advisers, but it needs restating that in two basic areas, this administration has failed very badly. These are in the areas of securing lives and property of citizens and promoting their welfare; the two basic functions of any government. The manifestation of organized violence and rampant violent crimes have rendered life for all Nigerians more precarious. The national assembly has moved into the vacuum created by incompetence and weak political will of the administration to expose how improvements in citizens’ welfare have been hijacked by rampant and entrenched corruption. The President lost much of his turf to organized violence and crimes, and the opportunism of politicians in the legislative arms. He will find it increasingly difficult to put out policies which involve additional hardships for the public, such as the forthcoming review on electricity tariff, if Nigerians hear only of stolen billions.
The second element which has defined the character of President Jonathan’s presidency, and is likely to define his agenda, is his political future beyond 2015. By now, when old man Clark speaks, the wise listen with rapt attention. When old man Clark and Pastor Oritsejafor say the same thing only the most foolish will be indifferent. And both say the only obstacle between Jonathan and another term from 2015 is a stubborn northern resistance, but it will be successfully challenged. Jonathan will run again in 2015 as it is his right to do, and in his interest to do. Others have done it before him, and those opposed to him are only doing so because he is from where he comes from. Nothing about competence, track record, ability or proven capacity to govern an increasingly difficult nation.
So Jonathan’s presidency will have one eye on managing an economy under assault from large scale corruption, and a polity threatened by organized violence and debilitating crimes; and the other eye on consuming maneuvers for 2015. How does he intend to handle these two simultaneously? Or, more significantly, what does he have that will enable him do this successfully? He certainly cannot rely on his public service to shore up deficiencies in integrity, competence and courage, when it is being routinely assaulted by arbitrariness, impunity and corruption. His entire arsenal of institutions and mechanisms intended to prevent the types of outright theft and fraud we see have been rendered laughable by the public stunts of the legislature which uses its oversight powers to show how a poor manager President Jonathan is. He will find it difficult to rely on the nation’s security asset to put an end to the insurgency which is crippling the north and threatening the rest of the nation, because it is more a part of the problem, than its solution. And though the brand new PDP leadership he has just helped install may give him some comfort, his party’s stranglehold on the nation’s political terrain is by no means guaranteed.
The problem for President Jonathan is that Nigerians are not sure who he is, or what he can do. If what they have seen of him in terms of managing crises, the economy or corruption is the Jonathan who wanted so badly to become President this time last year, they won’t be impressed. If there is more to President Jonathan than what Reuben Abati, C.K Clark or Pastor Oritsejafor say, he should show himself to Nigerians. The nation must not be run all the way to 2015, the way President Jonathan has run it so far.
Monday, May 21, 2012
2015, OR SOMETHING LIKE IT
“I discovered that being a president is like riding a tiger. A man has to keep on riding or be swallowed”
Harry S. Truman.
You would be forgiven if you think we are already in 2015, or thereabouts, and the election campaigns are in full swing. We are watching a drama unfold, which has many parts that are chilling in their effects. In a few days, President Jonathan will be celebrating his first year in office as a President sworn-in after an election he contested as a candidate. The quarrels over the comment made by General Muhammadu Buhari regarding the 2015 elections are unlikely to have died down by then. This will be unfortunate for a presidency eager to roll out the drums and reel out items of achievement in the transformation agenda. Just one year into a Presidency that was born of frightening rancour and deep damage to the polity, we are being reminded that we are still deep in the woods.
General Buhari had said that if the 2015 elections do not substantially improve on the quality of the elections of 2011, there will be much bloodshed, and everyone will be the loser. He had chosen the Hausa adage of a fight between a dog and a monkey, in which both are substantially bloodied, and it is difficult to tell a winner. The allusion to blood has drawn the heaviest salvos, not surprisingly, from an administration and a party which are grappling with serious issues of escalating violence, and are yet to recover from the bitter and destructive reactions to the outcome of the 2011 presidential elections in parts of the north. The smell of blood in General Buhari’s comment brought out all the sharks: the President’s corner reminded the nation that the General is not a democrat; is un-electable; is a prophet of doom and gloom who is unfit to lead; and that he should be held solely responsible for any violence he is predicting. The PDP rolled out the big guns it reserves for big occasions, and lambasted the General in its traditional and new language.
The General’s party and its allies rallied around him, firing back in language and with passion fit for real war. The dust is still much in the air and the meaning of “bloodied dog, bloodied monkey” is being very carefully scrutinized, and General Buhari is basking in a limelight he has not enjoyed since the aftermath of the 2011 elections. Even northern governors are being affected by this awesome quarrel, and they recently resolved, after their recent meeting in Kaduna, that they will facilitate the emergence of a northern candidate, presumably after they succeed in collapsing all partisan boundaries.
It is important to seek for deeper reasons behind this latest outbreak of squabbles over elections. The outward manifestations of the issues are not difficult to discern. The comments he made and the reactions to them have reminded the nation that General Buhari is very much a factor in Nigeria politics. They are also strong signals that the recent talks over political and electoral alliance between the CPC and ACN represent a real threat to the PDP. Then there is the evidence that the our democratic system does not distinguish periods between governance and partisan, or electoral campaign. 2015 is upon us, whether we realize it or not.
But a worrying question is one which should ask why all this heat will be generated by remarks about the linkages between elections and violence. This is certainly not the first time General Buhari will warn over the dangers of rigged elections, and it will not be his last. Nor is he the only Nigerian who believes that unless our elections successively improve the manner they reflect popular will, they will alienate more and more Nigerians, and many voters and other citizens will take up violence as a means of protesting perceived abuses of the electoral process. Who would believe that it will be all tranquility and peace if the elections of 2015 do not radically improve on 2011, and do so in a manner ordinary voters will recognize and accept?
There is a basic issue about the 2011 elections which represents a serious problem. The presidency and INEC, and a substantial percentage of Nigerian citizenry says the elections were generally good, and represent a new benchmark for credible elections in Nigeria. Another significant proportion of the citizenry says they were substantially rigged, and do not reflect the popular will. Civil society is overwhelmingly critical of the elections, although it says they were better than previous ones. The international community, which has since become a major player in our electoral process, says it was acceptable, and certainly more acceptable than prolonged strife over results.
Now, if you do not accept that the 2011 elections were substantially flawed, why should you go out of your way to fix them? Because Buhari says you must do it, or else blood will flow? And, conversely, why should the electoral process be so comprehensively condemned (and by implication, thoroughly reformed), because politicians who serially lose elections say they are rigged? What, or who will motivate a genuine review of the 2011 elections, and an informed and dispassionate improvement on its manifest weaknesses? INEC will say it has a routinized review mechanism, and will study all the elements of the 2011 elections, plug loopholes, and address weaknesses subject to financial and other support from government. Will that satisfy General Buhari and his supporters and the opposition? The administration will say what INEC and the democratic process need is constructive and genuine critique of our elections, and not wholesale condemnations by politicians who lose elections. It will say it is ready to work with INEC, civil society and the international community to improve upon the 2011 elections, which were, in any case, good. Will this satisfy Buhari and his supports and the opposition?
The most worrying dimension of these quarrels is that they expose the links between the quality of our politicians and of our electoral process. If elections are only free and fair when we win them, and winners will emerge irrespective of the quality of the elections, and then defend the elections they may have rigged as free and fair, then we will never conduct credible and acceptable elections in Nigeria. Ordinary voters who are far from the intricate but damaging manipulations of the electoral process take their cues from the reactions of politicians who win or lose elections. In situations where stakes are raised to extremely high levels by politicians and supporters, suggestions of rigged elections resonate with profound consequences. On the other hand, such is the manner politicians manipulate divisive and parochial values among Nigerian voters, that few voters will question results if they satisfy narrow political goals.
The way things stand now, if General Buhari changes his mind and decides to re-contest as a candidate in the 2015 presidential elections, either on his party’s platform or as a coalition candidate, it is very likely that President Jonathan’s yet-to-be-declared but active interest in running again win be given substance by an alliance between the south south and the south east. As if the dangerous slide we now see into parochialism is not enough, this will polarize the nation even further. To add a massive dispute over elections whose credibility is already being questioned may be too much for this nation to process.
Harry S. Truman.
You would be forgiven if you think we are already in 2015, or thereabouts, and the election campaigns are in full swing. We are watching a drama unfold, which has many parts that are chilling in their effects. In a few days, President Jonathan will be celebrating his first year in office as a President sworn-in after an election he contested as a candidate. The quarrels over the comment made by General Muhammadu Buhari regarding the 2015 elections are unlikely to have died down by then. This will be unfortunate for a presidency eager to roll out the drums and reel out items of achievement in the transformation agenda. Just one year into a Presidency that was born of frightening rancour and deep damage to the polity, we are being reminded that we are still deep in the woods.
General Buhari had said that if the 2015 elections do not substantially improve on the quality of the elections of 2011, there will be much bloodshed, and everyone will be the loser. He had chosen the Hausa adage of a fight between a dog and a monkey, in which both are substantially bloodied, and it is difficult to tell a winner. The allusion to blood has drawn the heaviest salvos, not surprisingly, from an administration and a party which are grappling with serious issues of escalating violence, and are yet to recover from the bitter and destructive reactions to the outcome of the 2011 presidential elections in parts of the north. The smell of blood in General Buhari’s comment brought out all the sharks: the President’s corner reminded the nation that the General is not a democrat; is un-electable; is a prophet of doom and gloom who is unfit to lead; and that he should be held solely responsible for any violence he is predicting. The PDP rolled out the big guns it reserves for big occasions, and lambasted the General in its traditional and new language.
The General’s party and its allies rallied around him, firing back in language and with passion fit for real war. The dust is still much in the air and the meaning of “bloodied dog, bloodied monkey” is being very carefully scrutinized, and General Buhari is basking in a limelight he has not enjoyed since the aftermath of the 2011 elections. Even northern governors are being affected by this awesome quarrel, and they recently resolved, after their recent meeting in Kaduna, that they will facilitate the emergence of a northern candidate, presumably after they succeed in collapsing all partisan boundaries.
It is important to seek for deeper reasons behind this latest outbreak of squabbles over elections. The outward manifestations of the issues are not difficult to discern. The comments he made and the reactions to them have reminded the nation that General Buhari is very much a factor in Nigeria politics. They are also strong signals that the recent talks over political and electoral alliance between the CPC and ACN represent a real threat to the PDP. Then there is the evidence that the our democratic system does not distinguish periods between governance and partisan, or electoral campaign. 2015 is upon us, whether we realize it or not.
But a worrying question is one which should ask why all this heat will be generated by remarks about the linkages between elections and violence. This is certainly not the first time General Buhari will warn over the dangers of rigged elections, and it will not be his last. Nor is he the only Nigerian who believes that unless our elections successively improve the manner they reflect popular will, they will alienate more and more Nigerians, and many voters and other citizens will take up violence as a means of protesting perceived abuses of the electoral process. Who would believe that it will be all tranquility and peace if the elections of 2015 do not radically improve on 2011, and do so in a manner ordinary voters will recognize and accept?
There is a basic issue about the 2011 elections which represents a serious problem. The presidency and INEC, and a substantial percentage of Nigerian citizenry says the elections were generally good, and represent a new benchmark for credible elections in Nigeria. Another significant proportion of the citizenry says they were substantially rigged, and do not reflect the popular will. Civil society is overwhelmingly critical of the elections, although it says they were better than previous ones. The international community, which has since become a major player in our electoral process, says it was acceptable, and certainly more acceptable than prolonged strife over results.
Now, if you do not accept that the 2011 elections were substantially flawed, why should you go out of your way to fix them? Because Buhari says you must do it, or else blood will flow? And, conversely, why should the electoral process be so comprehensively condemned (and by implication, thoroughly reformed), because politicians who serially lose elections say they are rigged? What, or who will motivate a genuine review of the 2011 elections, and an informed and dispassionate improvement on its manifest weaknesses? INEC will say it has a routinized review mechanism, and will study all the elements of the 2011 elections, plug loopholes, and address weaknesses subject to financial and other support from government. Will that satisfy General Buhari and his supporters and the opposition? The administration will say what INEC and the democratic process need is constructive and genuine critique of our elections, and not wholesale condemnations by politicians who lose elections. It will say it is ready to work with INEC, civil society and the international community to improve upon the 2011 elections, which were, in any case, good. Will this satisfy Buhari and his supports and the opposition?
The most worrying dimension of these quarrels is that they expose the links between the quality of our politicians and of our electoral process. If elections are only free and fair when we win them, and winners will emerge irrespective of the quality of the elections, and then defend the elections they may have rigged as free and fair, then we will never conduct credible and acceptable elections in Nigeria. Ordinary voters who are far from the intricate but damaging manipulations of the electoral process take their cues from the reactions of politicians who win or lose elections. In situations where stakes are raised to extremely high levels by politicians and supporters, suggestions of rigged elections resonate with profound consequences. On the other hand, such is the manner politicians manipulate divisive and parochial values among Nigerian voters, that few voters will question results if they satisfy narrow political goals.
The way things stand now, if General Buhari changes his mind and decides to re-contest as a candidate in the 2015 presidential elections, either on his party’s platform or as a coalition candidate, it is very likely that President Jonathan’s yet-to-be-declared but active interest in running again win be given substance by an alliance between the south south and the south east. As if the dangerous slide we now see into parochialism is not enough, this will polarize the nation even further. To add a massive dispute over elections whose credibility is already being questioned may be too much for this nation to process.
LURKING WITH INTENT
“The public say they are getting cynical about politicians. They should hear how politicians talk about them.” George Walden
General Muhammadu Buhari’s assertion that there will be crises if the elections of 2015 are not free and fair have drawn a torrent of reactions which are profound in their revelations. The General was reported to have said that if the government, or the government and INEC, (or “they”) fail to organize credible elections, there will be, as in Hausa language, a bloodletting involving the dog and the baboon. The expression is usually made in situations where fights draw substantial blood from all parties, and there are difficulties in identifying outright winners. The use of the word “blood” appears to have drawn the biggest flack from his opponents. Fellow members of the opposition have also rallied around him, denouncing criticisms against him and further justifying his comments.
Suddenly, the political atmosphere hit a high temperature, certainly the highest since the riots which followed the announced victory of President Jonathan in last year’s Presidential elections. The deluge of condemnation and stinging criticisms from President Jonathan’s stable and his party were matched by strident defence and equally scathing criticisms of General Buhari’s critics. A nation watched a drama involving very strong emotions and words, and wondered what the fuss is all about.
And the nation is justified in asking what all this excitement is about, and may have reached some conclusions already. One of these may be that General Buhari represents a potent source of concern in government and PDP circles, perhaps the most potent around. Just when you thought the aging General may be preparing to honour his word that he will not contest another election after 2011, the political limelight is thrown squarely on him over remarks millions of Nigerian have heard from him and from many others many times before. It couldn’t possibly be merely a reaction to comments which hint that a rigged election triggers massive social unrest, and that the biggest lesson of the aftermath of 2011 is that 2015 must be better. Could it be, then, the result of a perception that General Buhari’s long silence is over, and he may be preparing the grounds for his campaign in 2015? Could it be that talks of political alliance between the CPC, ACN and possibly a few more parties in being taken very seriously by the administration and the PDP? Could it be the result of worrying concerns that the pervasive nature of violence in the lives of Nigerians is already a major challenge, and a nervous administration abhors any further hint at another dimension to our already violence-driven existence?
Whatever he intended to achieve by the remarks he made, General Buhari has made much more capital from them than would have been reasonably expected. Given the manner of the reactions to his comments, we can discern two possible explanations. One is that General Buhari has squarely re-positioned himself as the issue in Nigerian politics. The second, related, explanation is that he will now find it very difficult to resist the pressure not to run again in 2015. Although the President’s corner had made efforts to rope in people like el-Rufai in the salvos they fired at Buhari, their reactions merely showed the General in greater limelight.
But it is important to seek a deeper understanding of the reasons behind the reactions of the administration and the PDP, other than being knee-jerk. If General Buhari is condemned for suggesting that blood will flow if the 2015 elections are rigged, it is reasonable to ask why anyone will believe that blood will not flow if elections are rigged in 2015, whether General Buhari says so or not. Could the administration be living under the illusion that 2011 was a mishap, a glitch and a one-off event that will not recur, if the same circumstances are recreated? Is it possible that no one in authority is looking into the remote and immediate causes of the riots which followed the Presidential election? Could it be the case that the administration and INEC see those events merely as the product of the hysteria which General Buhari created, and the manner citizens literally translated his demand that votes must be protected all the way? Could someone be operating under the illusion that election – related violence, particularly riots which follow announced results were created by General Buhari, and will die as soon as he does not even hint that people should protect their votes?
The comments and reactions to General Buhari’s comments should worry Nigerians. In the first place, the suggestion by General Buhari that there are people out there who could choose to conduct free and fair, or rigged elections is very worrying. If someone like the General could hint that the electoral process is under the control of interests which cannot be influenced or affected by him, his party or even the Nigerian people, it is reasonable to ask what will motivate the administration and INEC to conduct elections that are better than 2011? Secondly, the comment is likely to distance more citizens and voters from the electoral process. What is the point, many voters will say, when they labored to register; labored to vote; and some of them even protested and rioted when they thought the results were not reflections of popular will, and now they are hearing that 2015 will not necessarily be better; and if it is not, there will be even more blood on the streets? Thirdly, many of General Buhari’s supporters will be frightened when they hear him talk of violence in 2015.
No one has gained anything from the riots of 2011. Not a single vote was re-allocated; not a single seat was gained by all the fire and the blood; and all the committees and enquires have not shown how the political and electoral process should be re-engineered to stop the poor from spilling their blood and the blood of others at every election. Finally, General Buhari may not have been responsible for the dangerous maneuvers in the PDP which produced Jonathan as candidate but which exposed the nation’s critical faultlines; he may not have been responsible for the weaknesses and the shortcomings of INEC; but he should know that damaging propanga has irretrievably linked him with the riots that followed the 2011 elections in the minds of many Nigerians. For a man who may still aspire to lead a nation, or at least have his party work to replace the PDP, his image and standing, particularly in the south and some parts of the north will not be helped by his insistence on being personally responsible for providing the linkages between political contest and the dangers of routinely-rigged elections.
Which brings us to the issue of General Buhari’s political future. Now that the flack he has drawn seem to suggest that he represents a major threat to the PDP, the hands of those in the CPC who argue that he should stay firmly in the fray and contest again in 2015 would have been strengthened. His body language also appears to suggest that he will solve the emerging rancour over his successor by choosing to remain active. It is safe to say that if General Buhari does stay active, and chooses to fly his party’s flag in 2015 possibly in an alliance with the ACN, the PDP will dig in deeper in its resistance against this potentially-winning combination. President Jonathan’s yet-to-be-declared, but active interest to run again in 2015 will receive a boost from a south-south/south-east alliance. The nation will again be polarized, perhaps more dangerously then it was in 2011. In that event, both Buhari and Jonathan will be serious political liabilities in a nation desperate for some means to re-invent an all-inclusive political process.
The quarrels over the possibility that 2015 elections will be rigged, and that this will create massive bloodshed should focus the nation’s attention on preparations for credible elections in 2015. The main problem at this stage is that the administration, INEC, many sections of the country which support Jonathan, and sections of the international community which says any type of election is better than strife in Nigeria, insist that the 2011 elections was one of the best organized. Many others disagree, including Buhari and his supporters. So if 2011 was good, what should be improved? Are we going to go to 2015 with same candidates, the same bitterness, the same INEC, and a citizenry which takes its pound of flesh instantly every time it feels cheated at the polls?
General Muhammadu Buhari’s assertion that there will be crises if the elections of 2015 are not free and fair have drawn a torrent of reactions which are profound in their revelations. The General was reported to have said that if the government, or the government and INEC, (or “they”) fail to organize credible elections, there will be, as in Hausa language, a bloodletting involving the dog and the baboon. The expression is usually made in situations where fights draw substantial blood from all parties, and there are difficulties in identifying outright winners. The use of the word “blood” appears to have drawn the biggest flack from his opponents. Fellow members of the opposition have also rallied around him, denouncing criticisms against him and further justifying his comments.
Suddenly, the political atmosphere hit a high temperature, certainly the highest since the riots which followed the announced victory of President Jonathan in last year’s Presidential elections. The deluge of condemnation and stinging criticisms from President Jonathan’s stable and his party were matched by strident defence and equally scathing criticisms of General Buhari’s critics. A nation watched a drama involving very strong emotions and words, and wondered what the fuss is all about.
And the nation is justified in asking what all this excitement is about, and may have reached some conclusions already. One of these may be that General Buhari represents a potent source of concern in government and PDP circles, perhaps the most potent around. Just when you thought the aging General may be preparing to honour his word that he will not contest another election after 2011, the political limelight is thrown squarely on him over remarks millions of Nigerian have heard from him and from many others many times before. It couldn’t possibly be merely a reaction to comments which hint that a rigged election triggers massive social unrest, and that the biggest lesson of the aftermath of 2011 is that 2015 must be better. Could it be, then, the result of a perception that General Buhari’s long silence is over, and he may be preparing the grounds for his campaign in 2015? Could it be that talks of political alliance between the CPC, ACN and possibly a few more parties in being taken very seriously by the administration and the PDP? Could it be the result of worrying concerns that the pervasive nature of violence in the lives of Nigerians is already a major challenge, and a nervous administration abhors any further hint at another dimension to our already violence-driven existence?
Whatever he intended to achieve by the remarks he made, General Buhari has made much more capital from them than would have been reasonably expected. Given the manner of the reactions to his comments, we can discern two possible explanations. One is that General Buhari has squarely re-positioned himself as the issue in Nigerian politics. The second, related, explanation is that he will now find it very difficult to resist the pressure not to run again in 2015. Although the President’s corner had made efforts to rope in people like el-Rufai in the salvos they fired at Buhari, their reactions merely showed the General in greater limelight.
But it is important to seek a deeper understanding of the reasons behind the reactions of the administration and the PDP, other than being knee-jerk. If General Buhari is condemned for suggesting that blood will flow if the 2015 elections are rigged, it is reasonable to ask why anyone will believe that blood will not flow if elections are rigged in 2015, whether General Buhari says so or not. Could the administration be living under the illusion that 2011 was a mishap, a glitch and a one-off event that will not recur, if the same circumstances are recreated? Is it possible that no one in authority is looking into the remote and immediate causes of the riots which followed the Presidential election? Could it be the case that the administration and INEC see those events merely as the product of the hysteria which General Buhari created, and the manner citizens literally translated his demand that votes must be protected all the way? Could someone be operating under the illusion that election – related violence, particularly riots which follow announced results were created by General Buhari, and will die as soon as he does not even hint that people should protect their votes?
The comments and reactions to General Buhari’s comments should worry Nigerians. In the first place, the suggestion by General Buhari that there are people out there who could choose to conduct free and fair, or rigged elections is very worrying. If someone like the General could hint that the electoral process is under the control of interests which cannot be influenced or affected by him, his party or even the Nigerian people, it is reasonable to ask what will motivate the administration and INEC to conduct elections that are better than 2011? Secondly, the comment is likely to distance more citizens and voters from the electoral process. What is the point, many voters will say, when they labored to register; labored to vote; and some of them even protested and rioted when they thought the results were not reflections of popular will, and now they are hearing that 2015 will not necessarily be better; and if it is not, there will be even more blood on the streets? Thirdly, many of General Buhari’s supporters will be frightened when they hear him talk of violence in 2015.
No one has gained anything from the riots of 2011. Not a single vote was re-allocated; not a single seat was gained by all the fire and the blood; and all the committees and enquires have not shown how the political and electoral process should be re-engineered to stop the poor from spilling their blood and the blood of others at every election. Finally, General Buhari may not have been responsible for the dangerous maneuvers in the PDP which produced Jonathan as candidate but which exposed the nation’s critical faultlines; he may not have been responsible for the weaknesses and the shortcomings of INEC; but he should know that damaging propanga has irretrievably linked him with the riots that followed the 2011 elections in the minds of many Nigerians. For a man who may still aspire to lead a nation, or at least have his party work to replace the PDP, his image and standing, particularly in the south and some parts of the north will not be helped by his insistence on being personally responsible for providing the linkages between political contest and the dangers of routinely-rigged elections.
Which brings us to the issue of General Buhari’s political future. Now that the flack he has drawn seem to suggest that he represents a major threat to the PDP, the hands of those in the CPC who argue that he should stay firmly in the fray and contest again in 2015 would have been strengthened. His body language also appears to suggest that he will solve the emerging rancour over his successor by choosing to remain active. It is safe to say that if General Buhari does stay active, and chooses to fly his party’s flag in 2015 possibly in an alliance with the ACN, the PDP will dig in deeper in its resistance against this potentially-winning combination. President Jonathan’s yet-to-be-declared, but active interest to run again in 2015 will receive a boost from a south-south/south-east alliance. The nation will again be polarized, perhaps more dangerously then it was in 2011. In that event, both Buhari and Jonathan will be serious political liabilities in a nation desperate for some means to re-invent an all-inclusive political process.
The quarrels over the possibility that 2015 elections will be rigged, and that this will create massive bloodshed should focus the nation’s attention on preparations for credible elections in 2015. The main problem at this stage is that the administration, INEC, many sections of the country which support Jonathan, and sections of the international community which says any type of election is better than strife in Nigeria, insist that the 2011 elections was one of the best organized. Many others disagree, including Buhari and his supporters. So if 2011 was good, what should be improved? Are we going to go to 2015 with same candidates, the same bitterness, the same INEC, and a citizenry which takes its pound of flesh instantly every time it feels cheated at the polls?
PARTS OF A WHOLE*
We could safely identify a number of fallacies which feed the current discussions around the nature of the present structure of our nation, and its future. All these fallacies are rooted in the historic tendency of the Nigerian elite to revisit the manner in which they compete, and the peculiar manner in which ethno-geophical and religious pluralism are manipulated in this competition. The current pitch of the debate regarding geo-politics, re-engineering the Nigerian State and its chances of failure, disintegration or survival is itself a function of a number of issues:
i. One is the destructive impact of large-scale corruption which is exposing the basic skeleton of the State in a most dangerous manner. The Nigerian leadership and elite are losing the last vestiges of credibility because of the routinized subversion of the democratic process, and the systematic pillage of the resources of the people;
ii. The threat posed by criminality and violence, which have stretched the security apparatus of the Nigerian State to a point where it is being seriously doubted whether the State can continue to perform one of the most basic functions of any State, which is the protection of the lives and property of citizens. These threats go way beyond the Boko Haram insurgency, although this particular threat represents its most potent and dangerous challenge. Routine and endemic killings in towns and villages, many with remote or immediate links to ethno-religions conflicts are also major threats. So are the routinized crimes of kidnappings and armed robbery which have taken up residences in many parts of the country.
¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬*Text of a Lecture delivered at the Symposium on “Political and Socio-Economic Challenges and the Muslim Ummah” organized by Muslim Ummah, Kaduna State Branch, 19th – 20th May, 2012.
**Visiting Reader in Political Science, Usumanu Danfodiyo university Sokoto, and Executive Chairman, D.I.T.V/Alheri Radio, Kaduna.
*** I have made comments on the current debate on restructuring Nigeria in my blog site, www.baba-ahmed.blogspot.com.
The latent threat of insurgency in the Niger Delta which has deep roots with politics in the area is also a major threat;
iii. Elite fractionalization which has become pronounced since 1997, and the increasing perception that it will be impossible to have a credible and crises-free elections and the emergence of truly national leadership in Nigeria;
iv. The failure of the political elite to provide solutions to all these problems, and hence the resort to historic tendencies to the old divide-and-rule elite tactics.
2. The fallacies which are fed by these underlying structural limitations of the Nigerian elite can be summarized as:
a. The falsehood that the Nigerian nation is built on the twin pillars of illegitimacy, and ethnic groups which have not yielded their rights to live alone or together in the modern Nigerian state;
b. The falsehood that the Nigerian federation is a federation of elites, States tribes or religions, and not of citizens and voters;
c. The falsehood that elites can determine whether the Nigerian State survives, fails, disintegrates or is restructured, and citizens have little say in the matter;
d. The falsehood that geo-political zones represent political sub-entities, and larger ethnic groups can be reference points to the determination of the nature and the structure of the Nigerian State, and the over 260 ethnic groups and 160 million Nigerian citizens do not represent basic factors in any discussions on Nigeria’s structure or future;
e. The falsehood that outlines of an alternative basis for new federating units are already emerging in the attempts to engineer a monolithic political entity in the South West; the efforts to entrench the new-found but fragile unity in the South South; the serious search for the illusive Igbo unity; the half-hearted and confused manner in which the middle-belt seeks to create an identity; and the two zones in the far north which are being identified by violence and poverty.
f. The falsehood that an elite conclave under a sovereign or whatever type of conference will address the most basic of the weaknesses of the Nigerian state, which are its increasing failure to perform the basic job of a state, and the consequent evidence that insecurity and poverty will rise and feed more of its problems.
g. The falsehood that political stability, growth of the democratic process, economic progress, peace and sustained security will only come about if an event which comprehensively examines the structural limitations of the Nigerian State is allowed to hold, or holds in spite of official opposition and has its recommendations implemented, with or without government support.
3. The basic outlines of the Nigerian State today can be identified as:
a. A State where massive disputes around political succession, the organization of elections and the absence of legitimacy have alienated a substantial portions of the citizenry. No region of Nigeria is immune from this basic failure. Indeed, the scramble to build walls around political enclaves is itself a function of the failure of the leadership to address a most fundamental requirement to govern, which is basic elite cohesion;
b. A State which is basically characterized by pillage of resources and corruption in its vital institutions. Citizens are distant from the State, and become increasingly more so as leaders systematically and routinely subvert all the values of leadership. Security is impossible to guarantee solely by use of State power and resources; and citizens who feel they have little stake in the system, or little to protect or defend, will distance themselves from state organs and institutions. The most vital of all the institutions, the democratic institutions, will be increasingly subverted by a small elite, to the extent that voters and citizens feel leaders emerge without being elected, and elective offices go to the richest, most powerful, or most corrupt.
c. A State at the mercy of threats which understand and exploit its weaknesses and fault lines. The Boko Haram insurgency raises the issue of the absence of justice, equity and honesty in governance, although it does this in a manner which presents these issues as if they affect only Muslims. Ethno-religions conflicts are products of unfair distribution of political and economic resources, as well as the cynical exploitation of the failure of the Nigerian State to effectively mediate relations between ethnic and religious groups. Violent crimes and others such as kidnapping exploit a weak and corrupt security network. The linkages between politics and organized violence are becoming more pronounced, as the competition for elective offices and the resources of the State increasingly moves away from the ballot box and becomes determined by buttets and bullion vans.
d. Frightening levels of corruptions, not only of huge resources, but of basic values and institutions. As the political and democratic process becomes increasingly dependent on vast resources stolen from the public, the leadership and value systems they produce merely keep the vicious circle going. Stolen money provides stolen mandates; which are then used to steal more money. And the circle goes on;
e. Dangerous gaps which are daily increasing between the citizen and the Nigerian State. Stolen resources prevent the State from registering as an important factor in the lives of citizens. Failure to provide security and welfare for citizens erodes legitimacy and respect for leaders. In many parts of the country, new political arrangements as the solutions to poverty and insecurity are being falsely peddled. Yet the leaders who do so are from the some stock as the leaders from the zones from which distance is being created.
4. There are genuine reasons why Nigerians should worry over our current situation, for which we are told a conference or restructuring will provide a solution. What we need to appreciate are:
a. Nigeria has too many roots and branches in every village, community, state or region to be dissected and restructured along ethno-religions lines. This nation is much more firmly rooted than our elites and leaders like to believe, and every farmer, trader, artisan, housewife or labourer; and every village and community has paid its dues in the last 100 years to have a nation which should survive our current problems;
b. Our unity and survival as a nation has not been surrendered to elites and politicians with questionable legitimacy to do with them as they wish. Our nation will not fail because politicians fail to sort out their basic disputes. We will not be re-assigned, re-allocated, re-designed or re-organized on the basis of the wishes of a few members of the elite who see these as easier means of control.
c. Our unity is a unity of people with diverse ethno-religious identities, an organic unity of people, who are citizens of one nation.
d. No part of Nigeria will be safe or will progress beyond the insecurity or poverty of the others. The nature of our current challenges can only be addressed in a holistic manner;
e. The resources which God gave us belong to all of us. The tendency to seek for arrangements which keep more for a region, and deprives others of basic development resources is dangerous and self-defeating. The foundation for peace in any nation is a function of the manner the richest and the poorest are accommodated; and the degree to which wealth and poverty do not threaten unity or equity. No restructuring or isolation will make the citizens of the South West or South South safe from the negative effects of poverty in the north. Similarly, progress in parts of the country which encourage them should be welcomed, because affluence in the South West means northern farmers can sell more onions and cattle there; and use profits to expand. The prosperity, from legitimate income, of the South South should be welcomed in the north, because it boosts the strong economic ties between the regions, and is a solid source of resources and income for the north. Poverty and insecurity in the north is a serious threat to capital and enterprise from the south east, which is heavily dependent on investments and consumption in the north. Any threat to peace and security in the north central zone which affects the production and distribution of agricultural produce will severely damage the nation’s economy. All these are reasons why the nation’s foundations as a united country should be encouraged, not subverted by elites who solve problems by creting more problems.
5. All these are not to say that the Nigerian State is not showing pronounced signs of failing. Failure of the Nigeria State, which is actually a worse fate than break up or restructuring, will be the case when the Nigerian State fails to provide security, protect its territory, fails to prevent balkanization, produces multiple leadership and loses the monopoly over the use of violence. The Nigerian State will fail if its leaders fail to sustain a coherent and cohesive leadership over its critical institutions, including its security institutions; and civil society fails to organize a comprehensive resistance against failure. Those who advocate tribal conclaves or some other type of meetings to discuss our political structures and future use the fear of failure of the state as justification for their demands. The fundamental weakness of this position is that the elite who preach national conferences, restructuring or break-ups are basically the same people who are responsible for what the nation is today. Even if they do not, or have not exercised political power, they fail in terms of providing the wrong solutions for the wrong problems. For so long as the type of leaders we have continue to dominate the political level, it makes no difference how you restructure Nigeria; or how you break it up. It will remain the same, or all the parts will remain basically the same as they are.
The real challenge in terms of stopping the dangerous decline of the nation is to go beyond the agenda and schemes of fractions of the elite. A national political movement must emerge to raise real answers to the very serious questions which need to be asked of our nation. Some of these questions include:
a. What are the sources of the basic weaknesses of the Nigerian State?
b. Can we solve basic problems of unity and security by re-organizing the nature of the federal system?
c. Where should we locate our collective resolve and anger at the State of our nation, and how do we channel them constructively and productively?
d. In the event that state failure becomes an imminent reality, what can civil society do?
It will be difficult to take this debate to a national level without an increase in the crisis level of the Nigerian State. At this moment, our elite and leaders all tend to think that problems are regionalized and limited, and they can build walls around them or distance themselves from them. At some stage, the citizens of Nigeria will have to engage each other in some serious damage control, and it is reasonable to expect that issues which feed the current clamour for restructuring or balkanization of the Nigeria State will feature. Parts of the nation have issues and problems they will need to seriously thrash out before they engage the rest of Nigeria. In my view, these are some of the issues which will represent a genuine agenda of issues and concerns which the Nigerian people should take up:
i. The North should undertake a critical self-assessment in terms of its failure to manage its socio-cultural and political pluralism. It needs answers to questions over why faith has become a central issues in its politics, and the manner competition for political and economic resources are increasingly determined by faith. It needs to ask serious questions about the character of the faith of its Muslim population and its relationship with a secular western or Christian values and institutions. It needs to understand the feelings of simple Muslims, their dreams and aspirations, and the manner in which they can be processed through the political and democratic process. It needs to appreciate the changing nature of power relations between Muslims and Christians in many parts of the North, and of the critical linkages between the nature of our democratic process and the patterns of distribution of power and economic resources.
The north needs to understand why it has failed so spectacularly to develop its best two assets: its large human resource and vast agricultural potential. It needs to understand the dynamics of the Nigerian political economy, and take full advantage of its strength while limiting its weaknesses. It needs to appreciate the manner in which political competition exploits its cultural pluralism, and how it can build bridges among its communities and faiths. In a situation where it has majority of the population and voters, the north only needs a guaranteed fair electoral system to ensure that it remains a key actor in political competition.
The West will need to come to terms with the fact that it is nowhere near the politically and culturally homogenous entity it likes to believe it is. Attempts to paper over historic and contemporary cracks which exist will fail every time short-sighted opportunism and the challenges of responding to stimuli from the rest of Nigeria come calling. The West can build an island of relative economic prosperity, but it will be substantially dependent on the extensive linkages between its economy and the rest of the Nigerian economy. Politics will continue to expose the fragile nature of Yoruba politics, and it is easy to forget that only a few years ago, the PDP controlled majority of Yoruba State. The West needs a new roadmap on relating with a North with which it has deep, historical and cultural ties; on relating with the South South which it needs to stay in Nigeria as a safe and secure source of revenue and security; and on relating with the South East which it needs to deepen already extensive economic relations with. It should rid itself of the dangerous illusion that it can go its own way, because no other part of Nigeria is more Nigerian than the South West.
The South South needs to sober up over its current euphoria over a semblance of political unity, and economic prosperity. No region is more vulnerable to instability and threats of subversion than the South South. None needs Nigeria more than the South South. It cannot compete in isolation; or survive potentially damaging political squabbles, or the resistance from the rest of Nigeria if it moves too far away; or the machinations and strategic interests of the Western world which will emasculate it. The south south is tempted to threaten Nigeria with destruction of oil and gas resources, and could use this as a bargaining tool. But no region is as dependent on oil and gas resources as the south south.
The south east need Nigeria to prosper, but it has to do some serious self-appraisal. It is the most exposed zone in terms of presence in every part of Nigeria; but its towns and villages are virtual dens of crimes, forcing citizens to live nightmare existence. The moral and ethical tone of the people and communities needs a very critical self-assessment because the fabled industry and enterprise of the Igbo people is severely compromised by the endemic nature of crime in their communities. The Igbo believe they have not developed to their full potential in
Nigeria, and an Igbo presidency and additional states will unleash this potential. Yet the zone is in a deadly competition with the North for 2015, which could do serious damage to both regions. The south east is attempting to build a tribal enclave like the Yoruba are attempting under the ACN, but it suffers from a perennial split personality defect which will not let it decide whether it wants to go with or against Nigeria.
2. Nigerians should demand that real substantive issues be examined by the current initiatives to reform the constitution. These must include:
i. The cost of government;
ii. The structure of the federal system, and in particular, the need for a
structure do that does not serve only to produce leaders who steal public resources;
iii. The need to curb corruption;
iv. Improvements into the electoral process;
v. Improving national security, and the creation of outlets against periodic and inevitable ethno-religious conflicts;
vi. The creation of a nation that allows the unhindered expression of the faith and beliefs of individuals and groups;
vii. The identification of mechanisms and processes which will guarantee that all Nigerian children receive quality and affordable education.
I thank you.
Friday, May 11, 2012
JONATHAN’S WATCH
“There are three times in a man’s life when it’s useless to hold him to anything: when he is madly in love, drunk or running for office.”
Robert Mitchum.
A little over two years ago, President Umaru Musa YarAdua died, providing a natural solution to a messy political and legal logjam that was to haunt the rest of his planned four – year term. It is a sign of the present times and the conditions we live under that the Anniversary was barely noticed. There were certainly a lot more pages with paid adverts congratulating the Governor of Jigawa State for receiving an honourary degree than those which reminded the nation that its President died two years ago. Both his entrance and his exits were tumultuous events, and Umaru YarAdua’s life and death will be marked as significant watersheds in Nigerian history. He did not, strictly speaking, hand over the baton to President Jonathan. You could say he dropped it, and Jonathan had to pick it with considerable difficulty in a race which started with so much promise, finished in a most controversial manner.
Umaru YarAdua was a good but complex man. He had many good intentions, and a bag full of personal and political limitations. He came into the Presidency in 2007 on the back of the most condemned election; from a Governor in a state where he learned that Nigerians politics bred intense bitterness and took no prisoners. His entire campaign for the Presidency of Nigeria was planned, funded and carefully choreographed by others who saw huge opportunities to milk his Presidency. He tagged along, with his own agenda carefully tucked away, hoping that when, not if, he became President, he would make a clean break with history.
He began well, denouncing the election that brought him to power, and committing himself to reform the electoral process. He failed to do this, when it became clear that reform in the manner the Committee under Chief Justice M. L. Uwais proposed, would transform our electoral system beyond the capacity of his party, the PDP to control and manipulate. His commitment to entrench the rule of law and fight corruption remained hollow slogans, as corruption became entrenched in the circle which surrounded him, and the rule of law found expression only in pamphlets. Grand visions involving developments of infrastructure and reforms in the power sector, petroleum and gas and land administration were defeated by massive corruption which had dug in, and an indifferent and lethargic public service. A resolution of the crippling crimes under the name of militancy in the Niger Delta involved potentially dangerous and expensive concessions, and the jury is still out over the long-term value of the Amnesty Programme. A substantially weakened President was persuaded to give a shoot-at-sight order literally on his way out of the country when the Yusufiyya insurgency was threatening to overwhelm the Police in Maiduguri. In the execution of the order, the leader of the insurgency was executed, and the nation is being reminded of that act almost daily with bombs and bullets. An even weaker President was sold the dummy that tinkering with the rules of the public service under a tenure policy will transform the public service. The alarming crash in standards, efficiency and moral courage in the public service is the result the nation is paying for this folly. Competent and experienced hands are being retired at moments when they are most needed, and the shocking revelations and unprecedented levels of stealing around pensions and the subsidy scams are in reality evidence of the failure of the public service to protect the public and public resources from pillage.
A weak and a sick President is a liability to governance, but a weak and sick President who was propped up by interests which had scant regards and respect for the law or the national interest became a major threat. The undignified and untidy efforts made to prolong YarAdua’s Presidency and keep Jonathan away at all cost necessary (and unnecessary) did little justice to the personal ideals of Umaru himself who, for all his failings, actually saw power as a transient element. In sickness and in the manner his death came about, the foundations of a bitter succession and the perception of an parochial resistance against a Jonathan presidency took roots.
From the moment the law was turned on its head by a national resolve to end the drift after it became clear that Yar’Adua couldn’t continue, the Jonathan presidency was marked by an indelible perception that it had to fight every inch of the way against massive northern resistance. The underdog image was given a boost in the contest for the PDP ticket, and the gang-up of northern politicians in the PDP against Jonathan’s candidature created opportunities to tap into massive primordial sentiments and sympathies. Now a northern, Muslim enemy became easily identifiable, and the foundations of much of the character of our present political environment were laid.
President Jonathan’s full watch began on the ashes of four basically wasted years, when the nation moved from a crippled presidency, to one shackled by petty and destructive opportunism and fatal miscalculations. He came with a mentality that is substantially hostage to its recent past, and the riots which followed his announced victory further exposed dangerous faultiness which the political contest that produced his presidency had made more pronounced. Against a perceived far northern resistance, President Jonathan’s people whipped up their own regional passions. Our politics has never been more tribalized, and the centrality of faith in politics and governance never more pronounced.
With a mandate all of his own since 2011, the nation could legitimately ask what all that struggle by President Jonathan to become President was all about? To prove that he had a right to aspire and occupy the position, yes. To prove that South South people can ‘rule’ Nigeria, yes. To prove that the northern establishment could be humbled and humiliated, yes. But what about going beyond the pound of flesh? Is it purely coincidental that Jonathan’s watch has been marked by the most frightening manifestation of threats to our security, and revelations of mind-boggling corruption? Certainly, it is fair to say that he had inherited some of these problems, but Jonathan was part of the Presidency since 2007, and effectively President since 2010. To say his presidency has been crippled by incipient regional hostility, a determined insurgency and unspeakable corruption is akin to saying that thieves have made the night guard’s job difficult. The job of the guard is to keep the thieves away, and not use them as the excuse for perennial theft.
By any standards of judgment, President Jonathan’s watch is a difficult one. But he wanted job, and he got it. From the moment he sat in Yar’Adua’s chair, he called the shots. Now he is being judged by how he responds to the challenges he faces. Will he reign in run-away corruption by prosecuting people who swindled us of trillions in fraudulent subsidy? Can he prosecute the big names behind the pension scam; the collapse of the capital market; the scandalous sales or ‘dashing’ of our assets under the privatization programme? Can he find a way to limit and eliminate the dangers posed by the Boko Haram insurgency? Can he make a tangible difference between now and 2015 in the areas of power supply, unemployment among the youth and reform of the electoral process? The job of being a Nigerian President must be the most difficult in our current circumstance. It’s made more difficult because President Jonathan cannot blame anyone, if during his watch, Nigeria sinks deeper into crises.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)